Ontario's Plain-English Guide to Custom Home Buildingπ 705-533-1633 | βοΈ 1-866-868-6606 | βοΈ info@icfhome.ca
Drawers vs. Doors in Base Cabinets: Why the 15% Is the Best Money in the Kitchen
Kitchen Cabinets
Drawers or Doors Under the Counter? The Argument Ends the First Time You Kneel on the Floor
A base cabinet with a door and a shelf is a cave. You open it, crouch, move the thing in front to reach the thing behind, and the pot you wanted is at the back on the bottom shelf behind the slow cooker you have used twice. A drawer brings the whole cave to you. It costs more. It is the single best upgrade in a kitchen, and here is how much, and where.
What the difference costs
A 30-inch base cabinet with a door and a shelf is one box, one door, two hinges and a shelf. The same cabinet as a three-drawer stack is one box, three drawer boxes, three fronts and three pairs of runners, and the runners are the expensive part. At a semi-custom shop the drawer version costs about 40% more per cabinet. Across a kitchen where most of the base run goes to drawers, that is roughly 15% on the base cabinets, which is what the calculator adds when you tick “mostly drawers.” On a mid-grade 18-foot base run, call it $1,000 to $1,500. On the whole installed kitchen, about 5%.
For scale: that is less than the waterfall end on the island, less than the upgrade from level 1 granite to mid quartz, and you will use it forty times a day for twenty years. There is nothing else in the kitchen with that return.
Which cabinets get drawers, and which do not
Drawers, always
Every base cabinet that holds things you take out and put back: pots, pans, lids, baking sheets (vertical dividers in a deep drawer), small appliances, plastic containers, dish towels, the junk drawer, the drawer beside the range for utensils and oils. If you cook, the drawer stack beside the range is the one you will thank yourself for.
Doors, by necessity
The sink base, because the plumbing is in the way (a tip-out tray in the false drawer front is the consolation). The dishwasher and the range are appliances, not cabinets. The corner, which gets a lazy susan or a pull-out. A tall pantry, which wants roll-out shelves behind doors rather than drawers, so you can see the back. And the trash pull-out, which is a door on runners and the best thing in the kitchen after the drawers.
A typical 18-foot base run ends up with the sink base, the dishwasher, the range and the corner as doors or appliances, and everything else as drawers: usually three or four drawer stacks. That is what “drawer-heavy” means in the shop’s language.
The sizes that actually work
A three-drawer stack in a 34.5-inch-tall base cabinet is the standard: a shallow top drawer about 6 inches deep for utensils, and two deep drawers of 10 to 12 inches each for pots. Two deep drawers is the better configuration for the cabinet beside the range, because pots want depth, not count. A four-drawer stack with four shallow drawers is for the baking person, the one with the rolling pins and the measuring cups.
Width: 24 inches is the minimum for a pot drawer to hold a 12-inch frying pan with its handle. 30 and 36 are the useful widths; a 36-inch drawer holds a Dutch oven and a stock pot side by side. Drawers over 36 inches wide need heavier runners and sag at the front if they are loaded, so a 48-inch cabinet is usually two 24-inch stacks, not one wide one.
Depth: standard base cabinets are 24 inches deep, which gives a drawer box of about 21 inches. A deeper drawer is not better; things get lost at the back. The runner length matters more: full-extension runners bring the whole drawer out so you can see the back. Three-quarter extension leaves the back 5 inches inside the cabinet, which is where the lids go to die.
The hardware is the drawer
A drawer is only as good as its runners, and this is where cheap kitchens cheap out. Side-mount ball-bearing runners, the kind you see on the sides of the drawer box, cost the shop about $8 a pair, are rated for 75 to 100 pounds, and are fine for a utensil drawer. They are visible when the drawer is open, they are loud, and they do not have soft-close unless you pay more.
Undermount runners, Blum Tandem and the equivalents from Grass, Hettich and Salice, sit under the drawer box where you cannot see them, are rated for 100 to 170 pounds, close themselves softly from the last two inches, and are the reason a good kitchen’s drawers feel the way they do. They cost the shop $25 to $45 a pair. On a kitchen with 12 drawers that is $300 to $450 in parts, and most mid-grade lines include them now; ask by brand.
The drawer box itself: a dovetailed solid wood or plywood box is the mark of a shop that cares about the inside. A stapled particleboard box is what you get at the bottom of the range, and it is the first thing to fail when the drawer is overloaded. The quality checklist has you pull a drawer out and look; this is why.
Retrofitting drawers into a kitchen you already have
If the boxes are sound, a door-and-shelf base cabinet can be converted to roll-out shelves behind the existing door for $150 to $300 a cabinet installed, which gets you most of the benefit without new fronts. Shops and the big-box stores sell the kits. It is the cheapest fix for a kitchen that works except for the kneeling, and it is a good question to ask when you are deciding between refacing and replacing, which has its own page: refacing vs. replacement.
Questions people ask
Are drawers better than cabinets in a kitchen?
For base cabinets, yes, for anything you take out and put back. You see everything, reach everything, and never kneel. Uppers stay as doors; drawers above counter height do not work.
How much more do drawer base cabinets cost?
About 40% more per cabinet than a door and shelf, which works out to roughly 15% on the base run and about 5% on a whole installed kitchen. $1,000 to $1,500 on a typical mid-grade kitchen.
How many drawers should a kitchen have?
Three or four drawer stacks in a typical 18-foot base run, nine to twelve drawers, with the sink, dishwasher, range and corner as the exceptions. More if you bake or have a lot of small appliances.
Are soft-close drawers worth it?
Yes, and they come with undermount runners as a package on most mid-grade lines now. The cost is $25 to $45 a pair at the shop’s price. A kitchen without them, after a kitchen with them, sounds like a drum kit.
Can I put drawers in a corner cabinet?
Diagonal corner drawers exist and are expensive and mostly disappointing. A blind corner pull-out or a lazy susan does the job better. Put the drawers either side of the corner instead.
The whole thing in a sentence
Drawers wherever the plumbing and the appliances allow, undermount runners you can name the brand of, a dovetailed box you have pulled out and looked at, and the trash on a pull-out. That is about $1,500 on a typical kitchen and it is the part you will notice every day.
