Ontario's Plain-English Guide to Custom Home Buildingπ 705-533-1633 | βοΈ 1-866-868-6606 | βοΈ info@icfhome.ca
Drywaller vs Painter: Who Is Responsible for What, the Sign-Off Before Primer, the Defects Each Trade Owns, and How to Stop Paying for the Argument
Drywall, Taping & Painting
The Drywaller Says the Walls Were Fine. The Painter Says They Were Not Ready. You Have Paid Both. Here Is How It Should Have Gone, and What to Do Now.
This is the commonest dispute in interior finishing and I have refereed it more times than I would like. It happens because there is a handoff between two trades and nobody owns it. The taper leaves on Thursday, the painter arrives Monday, primes, and the primer shows every ridge, scratch and bubble the compound was hiding. The painter paints over them because he was paid to paint, not to tape. The taper is on another job. The homeowner sees seams. The fix is a sentence in the contract and fifteen minutes with a light on Friday. Here is the sentence, the inspection, and the list of which defects belong to whom.
Who owns which defect
| What you see | Whose | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A ridge, hump or depression you can feel along a joint | Taper | Compound shape. Paint cannot add or remove it. |
| Tape bubble, visible tape edge, loose tape | Taper | Bedding. Must be cut out and redone. |
| Cracked or wavy inside corner, dented or bare bead | Taper | Corner work. |
| Sanding scratches, fuzzed paper from oversanding | Taper (scratches), shared (fuzz shows only under paint; the painter should have flagged it at primer) | The primer inspection catches this. |
| Screw dimple showing as a dish | Taper | Three coats, not two. |
| Screw pop (a bump with cracked paint) | Hanger, or the house | Fastening into lumber that shrank. Normal in year one. Pops. |
| Joints show as dull or shiny stripes, flat to the touch | Painter | Flashing: no primer, wrong primer, thinned primer. Primer. |
| Joints show as texture difference under sidelight on Level 4, flat paint | Nobody, or the specifier | That is Level 4. Level 5 was needed under that light. 4 vs 5. |
| Joints show under eggshell/satin on Level 4 | Specifier; painter should have warned | Sheen on Level 4. Sheen. |
| Roller marks, lap marks, cut-in bands, drips, holidays | Painter | Application. Roller marks. |
| Peeling paint over a joint or a patch | Painter, usually | Primer over dust, or no primer. Taper if the compound was never sanded. |
| A wavy wall, a crowned stud, a corner out of plumb | Framer, or the house | Under everything. The taper floats what he can; it is in the walk-through before boarding. Before-drywall checklist. |
The handoff that prevents it
- Inspect the finished taping before primer, with the taper present or reachable. Dark room, light flat to the wall, then room light from the doorway. List every defect with blue tape. The checklist.
- The taper fixes the list. You sign off. A dated note: “Taping inspected and accepted for primer, subject to defects revealed at primer.” Email is fine.
- The painter primes with a named primer. He inspects under the primer and gives you a second list. New defects that are compound (ridges, pinholes, scratches) go back to the taper; the painter spot-primes the repairs.
- You sign off the primer. From here, anything visible after the finish coats is the painter’s, unless it is on the taper’s list of things he was told about and did not fix.
- Hold 10% from each trade until their list is done. It is what makes steps 2 and 3 happen.
The contract sentence: “Finished drywall to be inspected by the owner under a raking light before primer; the finisher corrects listed defects before primer; compound defects first visible after primer are corrected by the finisher and spot-primed by the painter; after finish coats, paint defects are the painter’s responsibility.” One sentence. Both contracts.
When it has already gone wrong
Photograph the walls under a raking light and under room light. Use the table above to sort the defects: feel the wall with your eyes closed; what you can feel is taping, what you can only see is paint. Write to each contractor separately with their list and the photos, politely, asking for a date to correct. Most will come, because the alternative is a review and a lien dispute over a few hundred dollars. If one refuses, the other can often fix it for a price, and that price is what you are out. If you paid in full with no holdback, this is the lesson; if you held 10%, you have the money to pay whoever fixes it. The $99 review will read your photos and tell you which column each defect is in, which is useful when both trades are telling you the other one.
Questions people ask
Who is responsible for drywall defects after painting?
Ridges, humps, bubbles, corner cracks and scratches you can feel are the taper’s. Flashing, roller marks, lap marks and peeling are the painter’s. Texture showing under sheen paint or raking light on a Level 4 wall is a specification problem. The inspection before primer is what sorts it out in time.
Should the painter inspect the drywall before painting?
Yes, and a good one does, with a light, and tells you what he found before he primes. A painter who primes over defects without a word has accepted them, in the eyes of most people who adjudicate these things.
Can one contractor do drywall and painting?
Some do, and it removes the handoff entirely: one measurement, one responsibility. Most drywall companies hang and tape only. If you hire separately, the inspection sentence goes in both contracts.
What if the drywaller refuses to come back?
Document it, write once asking for a date, then have the painter or another taper fix it from the holdback and tell the first one in writing why. If there was no holdback, small claims court is the route for the cost, and the photos are the case.
Put the sentence in the contract
The contract checklist has it as item 7, with the rest. The inspection checklist is the fifteen minutes with the light.
Sources and further reading
- Gypsum Association GA-214, Levels of Finish: the standard every “Level 4” and “Level 5” on a quote is supposed to mean. Free summary on the Gypsum Association site.
- Benjamin Moore Canada: product data sheets for the primers and paints named on these pages: coverage per gallon, recoat times and the right primer for new drywall.
- Tarion warranty coverage: what a new-home warranty covers for drywall cracks, nail pops and paint in year one and year two, and what it does not.
