Ontario's Plain-English Guide to Custom Home Building📞 705-533-1633 | ☎️ 1-866-868-6606 | ✉️ info@icfhome.ca
How to Lower Home Insurance Costs on a New Build in Ontario: The Decisions During Construction That Cut the Premium for Thirty Years
Costs and financing Insurance From a builder
How to Lower Home Insurance Costs on a New Build in Ontario: The Decisions During Construction That Cut the Premium for Thirty Years
Insurance is priced on statistics, and the statistics are about fire, water, wind and theft. Most of what decides your premium for the next thirty years is decided in the six months the house is being built, and almost none of it is on the builder’s upgrade sheet. Here is what the underwriter is actually looking at.
Short version: Build the house the underwriter likes: a non-combustible structure (ICF or masonry earns a construction discount with most insurers), a steel or Class A roof, a monitored alarm with cellular backup, a water leak shut-off valve with sensors and a freeze sensor, a battery-backed sump and a backwater valve, hard-wired interconnected smoke and CO alarms, a WETT-certified wood stove or none, and a lot within reach of a fire hall and a hydrant or a dry hydrant. Then insure it right: the real rebuild cost (not the market value), a higher deductible, bundled auto, claims-free and retiree discounts, and three quotes through a broker who understands custom and concrete construction. Expect the construction choices to cut 10 to 30 percent off the premium of the same house built conventionally.
What the underwriter prices
| Factor | What lowers the premium | What raises it |
|---|---|---|
| Construction type | Concrete, ICF, masonry; non-combustible structure | Wood frame; non-standard materials the underwriter cannot rate (straw, cob, some kits) |
| Roof | Steel, or Class A shingles under 15 years old | Old shingles, wood shakes |
| Fire protection | Distance to a fire hall under 8 km and a hydrant within 300 m, or a dry hydrant on a nearby lake; monitored smoke detection | Rural lot far from a hall; no hydrant |
| Water | Leak shut-off valve with sensors, battery sump, backwater valve, no finished basement contents at risk | Finished basement with no sump backup; a history of water claims on the street |
| Heating | Heat pump, gas or electric, professionally installed | Oil tank, a wood stove without a WETT certificate, any stove as primary heat |
| Security | Monitored alarm with cellular backup, deadbolts, cameras | None |
| Occupancy | Owner-occupied, full time | Seasonal, rental, vacant |
| Extras | None | Pool, hot tub, trampoline, home business, detached buildings |
| Location | Away from floodplains, wildland interface and the shoreline | On the water, in a floodplain, in the woods |
| Size and finish | Modest replacement cost | Large, high-finish houses cost more to rebuild and insure |
Build it in
- Walls: ICF or masonry. Most insurers rate concrete construction as superior for fire and wind and discount it; some need the broker to explain what ICF is, so bring the specification. ICF pros and cons covers what the wall does for everyone else.
- Roof: steel, or architectural shingles with the ice and water shield the Code requires; keep the receipts.
- Water: a motorized shut-off on the main with sensors at the water heater, laundry, dishwasher and sump; a battery or water-powered backup on the sump; a backwater valve on municipal sewer. Why new basements leak is why water is the most common claim.
- Alarms: interconnected hard-wired smoke and CO as the Code requires, plus a monitored system with cellular backup. Home security for a new build covers the rough-in.
- Heat: no oil tank; a heat pump or gas; a wood stove installed to the manufacturer’s clearances with a WETT inspection certificate, or a factory-built fireplace, or neither.
- Freeze protection: a connected thermostat and a freeze sensor, which also satisfies the winter-away clause most policies carry.
- Site: on a rural lot, a dry hydrant installation or a cistern can move the house into a better fire class; ask the township fire chief what counts.
- Documentation: photographs of the construction, the specification, the ESA certificate and the occupancy permit, in one folder for the broker.
Insure it right
- Rebuild value, not market value: the policy limit should be what it would cost to rebuild the house, which for a custom ICF house is higher than the broker’s software guesses for “two-storey, 2,400 square feet”; give them the contract price plus site work. Home insurance for a new build explains the exclusions that matter.
- Deductible: $2,500 or $5,000 instead of $1,000 cuts the premium noticeably; carry the difference in savings.
- Bundle auto and home; claims-free, retiree, new-home and mortgage-free discounts all exist and all have to be asked for.
- Endorsements you want: sewer backup, overland water where offered, guaranteed replacement cost; endorsements you may not: scheduled jewellery you do not own, a home business rider you do not run.
- Three quotes through a broker who places custom and rural houses; the insurer that does not have a box for ICF is not the right insurer.
- Review it every three years and after any upgrade over $10,000; an under-insured house is the most expensive saving there is.
What it is worth
On a typical custom house in Simcoe County, the construction choices above (concrete, steel roof, monitored alarm, leak and freeze protection, good fire access) run 10 to 30 percent below the premium of the same house built in wood with shingles and no alarm, which over thirty years is a five-figure number, and the leak shut-off alone prevents the claim that would double the premium for the next five. Home price versus lifetime cost is where insurance sits in the thirty-year arithmetic.
Related guides on this site
Sources and further reading
Questions people ask
How can I lower home insurance costs when building a new house?
Build with a non-combustible structure (ICF or masonry), a steel or Class A roof, a monitored alarm with cellular backup, a leak shut-off valve with sensors and a freeze sensor, a battery sump and backwater valve, hard-wired smoke and CO alarms, a WETT-certified stove or none, and a lot within reach of a fire hall and hydrant; then insure the real rebuild cost with a higher deductible, bundled auto and three quotes through a broker.
Does ICF construction lower home insurance?
With most insurers, yes: reinforced concrete walls are rated as superior for fire and wind and earn a construction discount. Some insurers need the broker to explain ICF; bring the specification.
Does a wood stove increase home insurance?
Yes, and some insurers will not write a policy without a WETT inspection certificate; a stove as the primary heat source raises it further. A factory-built fireplace or a heat pump avoids the surcharge.
Should I insure my house for market value or rebuild cost?
Rebuild cost: what it would take to rebuild the house today, excluding land. For a custom house that is often higher than the broker's estimate, so give them the actual construction cost plus site work, and ask about a guaranteed replacement cost endorsement.
Building in Simcoe County or on Georgian Bay?
We are ICFhome.ca, a family builder in Tiny Township with 45 years of custom homes behind us. Pick the path that matches where you are.
Reviewed and updated October 2026. Costs are Ontario ranges, not quotes; code references are to the Ontario Building Code in force at that date.
Thanks for the great article. I think these are really good tips on how to make sure that your home insurance costs stay low. I think that everybody needs to know about these really good tips. http://www.cehinsurance.com